The Law Office of Amy Muth, PLLC, defends adults and juveniles accused of sex offenses and other serious offenses in Washington’s state and federal courts. Many of our clients are accused of:
- Child rape
- Child molestation
- Indecent liberties
- Communicating with a minor for immoral purposes
- Possession, delivery, and distribution of child pornography
- Commercial sexual abuse of a minor
- Sexually motivated assault
- Other sexually motivated crimes, such as burglary, unlawful imprisonment and kidnapping
- We also represent individuals who are arrested in sting operations
We have attained acquittals, reductions or dismissals for people accused of all of the above charges.
- Not guilty, second degree rape: Client’s DNA had been located as evidence. Jury acquitted in forty minutes. (King County Superior Court)
- Not guilty, first degree assault of a child: Client’s early elementary-age son came to school with a bruise on his arm. When school staff asked him about it, child said his father hit him and made his mouth bleed for not cleaning his room. Law enforcement and CPS were called to the school. The parents arrived and CPS took their baby from her mother’s arms and their two elementary-age children. They were placed with another family member. The parents were devastated and felt completely powerless. At trial, it became apparent that their son was not assaulted, nobody knew where he got the bruise on his arm, he was disciplined for not cleaning his room and was probably still upset about that, and his mouth bled because he lost a tooth that day. Client was found not guilty. CPS ended their investigation with no adverse findings. All of the kids returned home. (Kitsap County Superior Court)
- Not guilty, child molestation, second degree: Client was accused of inappropriately touching his teenage niece during a sleepover. Niece reported the incident to her grandmother the same night. Niece had mental health needs that contributed to the allegation. Jury acquitted. (King County Superior Court)
- Not guilty, all charges: attempted second degree rape; indecent liberties; and unlawful imprisonment with sexual motivation: Client attended house party to celebrate daughter’s birthday; daughter was in early twenties. Client had too much to drink, went to use the bathroom and accidentally walked in on a female inside. She screamed and several people came running to her aide. The state believed he was trying to sexually assault her. Jury acquitted on all charges. (Kitsap County Superior Court)
- Not guilty, second degree assault, two counts, with firearm enhancements: Client was accused of shooting at police officers responding to a homicide. During a six-week trial, convinced the state’s ballistics expert to agree with defense case theory. Client was found guilty of a misdemeanor of unlawful discharge of a firearm and given a deferred sentence, which was later dismissed. (King County Superior Court)
- Not guilty, felony harassment-DV and VNCO-DV trial: Client and his former wife went through a contentious divorce. Client was accused of approaching ex-wife’s 11 year old son in a park in violation of a protection order and threatening him. Between the 911 call, the testimony of the officer and detective, testimony of client’s former wife, the 11 year old, defense investigator, and client, the jury acquitted on all counts.
- Not guilty verdict in several assault in the fourth degree-domestic violence cases.
- Dismissal, first degree child molestation and child rape: Individual found incompetent to stand trial, after two years of litigation and extensive expert consultation. (Kitsap County Superior Court)
- Dismissal, first degree child molestation involving female: Investigation revealed that the accuser had extensive mental health issues which impacted his credibility. (King County Superior Court)
- Dismissal, first degree child rape: Extensive investigation, including interview with accuser’s therapist, led to dismissal of charges. (King County Superior Court)
- Dismissal, SVP escape: Client was facing several years in prison. Client had been accused of going outside the range of his GPS device. Through the use of an expert on GPS, extensive interviews of neighbors and my client’s family, it was determined that the GPS device was deficient in accurately tracking my client’s whereabouts on the dates in question and my client was entirely innocent.
Charges Not Filed
- Rape charges not filed: Client investigated for third-degree rape charges following a sexual encounter on a boat with an intoxicated female. Interviewed client’s witnesses who corroborated client’s account and provided information to detective, which convinced detective not to refer case to the prosecutor for charging. (Skagit County)
- Child molestation charges not filed: Female client accused of sexually touching her foster son. Obtained mental health records of accuser that called accuser’s credibility into question. Provided package to detective, which convinced state not to file charges. (Skagit County)
- Indecent liberties charges not filed, juvenile court: Client accused of sexually touching another female at summer camp. After interviewing multiple witnesses, state declined to file charges.
- Child rape charges not filed: Client went through extremely contentious separation with partner who had Munchausen syndrome by proxy. After reviewing CPS records, blog postings by accuser, and several conversations with law enforcement and the prosecuting attorney, charges were declined. (King County Superior Court)
- Rape charges not filed: Client accused of sexually assaulting babysitter. Investigation revealed that babysitter had a history of engaging in deception. Located civil case involving same accuser where accuser’s significant mental health issues came to light. Successfully defended client against sexual assault protection order sought by accuser, and convinced prosecutor to decline charges.
- Rape charges not filed: Client investigated for sexual assault on college campus. Charges declined.
- Rape charges declined, juvenile court, multiple cases involving school peers: Represented juveniles accused of sexual misconduct involving school peers. Charges declined in multiple cases.
Reductions and Significant Sentencing Results
- Reduction, first degree child molestation to misdemeanor assault charges: Client was mother of child. Six months of expert consultation and investigation revealed that police had incorrectly reported that client failed a polygraph, daughter was improperly influenced by stepmother, and daughter had made accusation after attending a Girl Scout’s four-hour retreat on Stranger Danger. Client sentenced to 30 days of community service, not required to register as a sex offender.
- Sentence of probation and no jail time for federal child pornography charges: Sentence of probation (no jail time) for individual charged with possessing over 1500 images and 300 videos of child pornography; client faced 78-97 months in federal prison under the United States Sentencing Guidelines range. (U.S. District Court, Western District of Washington)
- Reduction, indecent liberties, multiple victims, to misdemeanor assault, no jail time, no sex offender registration: Represented health care professional charged with multiple sex offenses involving patients under his care. Investigation revealed that the accusers had significant impairments which impacted their credibility. Case reduced to misdemeanor assault, no jail time. (King County Superior Court)
- Reduction, first degree child molestation to misdemeanor assault, no jail time, no sex offender registration: Client accused of attempting to molest the seven-year-old daughter of a friend. Seven-year-old was put to bed during a party at her father’s friend’s house. Investigation revealed that client, who later entered that bedroom to sleep, had previously arranged to stay in that room that night and was unaware that the child was there, and that child was unable to state that defendant touched her sexually. Counseled client through successful psychosexual evaluation showing that client did not pose a risk of sexual harm to the community, which was presented to the prosecutor and used as the basis for the resolution. (Pierce County Superior Court)
- Reduction, attempted second degree child molestation to misdemeanor non-sex offense, no sex offender registration: Client sentenced to two months’ work release and not required to register as a sex offender. Subpoenaed 184 pages of mental health records of teenage accuser diagnosing accuser as a paranoid schizophrenic who was experiencing extreme mental disturbances around the time that she accused defendant of molesting her, and retained juvenile psychiatrist as expert prepared to conduct a competency examination of the accuser. (Clark County Superior Court)
- Reduction, child pornography charges to communicating with a minor immoral purposes, deferred sentence: Retained forensic computer expert who determined that client had inadvertently downloaded images of child pornography while downloading multiple adult pornography files. Expert concluded that client had deleted the images as he came across them, and many images were incorrectly labeled as adult images.
- Reduction, second degree rape and voyeurism charges to misdemeanor voyeurism, no registration: Client accused of videotaping himself digitally penetrating his girlfriend while she was asleep. Researched and briefed complex Fourth Amendment search and seizure to prosecution, which agreed to reduce. Client sentenced to no jail time.
- Reduction, second degree rape to misdemeanor assault: Client accused of forcibly raping a woman at a party. Client was in an alcohol blackout state and had no memory of the event. Extensive investigation revealed multiple inconsistencies in accuser’s account, leading to a substantial reduction of charges.
- Exceptional sentence downward, felony violation of a court order-domestic violence: Defense provided with 50 CD-ROMs of jail phone call recordings in violation of a domestic violence protection order. Presented extensive mitigation package to state which convinced state to recommend exceptional sentence downward instead of seeking convictions to place client in prison for 60 months.